Is Cinque Terre Being Loved to Death? The Hidden Costs of Tourism

Cinque Terre, a string of five picturesque villages on Italy’s Ligurian coast, has long been celebrated for its stunning landscapes, vibrant culture, and historic charm. However, the region is increasingly suffering from the pressures of overtourism, a phenomenon where the number of visitors exceeds the area’s capacity to manage them sustainably. The effects of this excessive tourism are multifaceted, impacting the environment, local economy, and the quality of life for residents. This article explores the hidden costs of tourism in Cinque Terre, focusing on the concentration of tourists in a small area, the minimal economic benefits to local businesses, the broader challenges of overtourism, and the actions being taken to address these issues.

The 2% Dilemma: Tourism Concentration

One of the most significant problems associated with overtourism in Cinque Terre is the extreme concentration of visitors in just a small fraction of the area. Despite the national park covering over 4,300 hectares, nearly all tourists are funneled into just 2-3% of the territory, primarily within the five iconic villages—Riomaggiore, Manarola, Corniglia, Vernazza, and Monterosso—and a few popular hiking trails​ (Finestre sull’Arte)

This concentration creates a range of issues. The narrow streets and small public spaces of these villages are often overwhelmed, making it difficult for both residents and visitors to move around comfortably. The pressure on infrastructure is immense, with local services such as waste management, water supply, and public transportation struggling to keep up with the demand. Furthermore, this intense focus on a small area leaves the vast majority of the park unexplored, potentially leading to a neglect of other beautiful, yet lesser-known parts of the region that could benefit from tourist activity.

Limited Economic Benefits for Local Businesses

Despite the large number of visitors, the economic benefits of tourism for local businesses in Cinque Terre are surprisingly limited. Cruise ships, in particular, contribute little to the local economy. Passengers often spend only a few hours in port, with minimal time to explore beyond a narrow range of activities. As a result, most of their spending is concentrated on a few tourist-focused businesses like souvenir shops or pre-arranged tours, which often have agreements with the cruise companies that limit the revenue flowing directly to local operators​ (EMU Today)

Moreover, cruise companies tend to capture the bulk of tourist spending through all-inclusive packages that cover meals, accommodations, and even shore excursions. This leaves little incentive for passengers to spend money on local food, independent shops, or services, further diminishing the economic impact on the community. The situation is exacerbated by the fact that many of the jobs generated by cruise tourism are low-wage and seasonal, offering little long-term economic stability for residents.

The Broader Challenges of Overtourism

The environmental and social impacts of overtourism in Cinque Terre are profound. The heavy foot traffic on popular trails leads to soil erosion and damage to the region’s delicate ecosystems. The influx of tourists also contributes to pollution, both from waste and from the transportation methods used to bring visitors to the area, such as cruise ships and buses​(ITALY Magazine).

Socially, the quality of life for residents has been negatively affected. The high demand for property has driven up housing prices, making it difficult for locals to afford to live in their own communities. The character of the villages is also changing, with many traditional businesses being replaced by tourist-oriented shops, altering the cultural landscape of the area​(Europeans24).

Actions Taken and Their Sufficiency

In response to these challenges, local authorities and the national park management have implemented several measures aimed at managing the flow of tourists and mitigating the impact on the environment. These include the introduction of the Cinque Terre Card, which regulates access to hiking trails and public transportation, and efforts to promote lesser-known areas of the park to distribute tourist activity more evenly across the region​(Finestre sull’Arte,ANSA.it).

Variable pricing for train tickets has also been introduced, with higher prices during peak times intended to encourage visitors to travel during less crowded periods. Additionally, there are ongoing discussions about implementing stricter controls on the number of visitors allowed in the villages each day, similar to measures being considered in other overtourism hotspots like Venice​.

While these actions are steps in the right direction, there is debate over whether they are sufficient to address the root causes of overtourism in Cinque Terre. Critics argue that more radical measures may be necessary, such as limiting the number of cruise ships allowed to dock or introducing a cap on the total number of tourists permitted in the park each year. Without more stringent controls, the region risks being overwhelmed by the sheer volume of visitors, with potentially irreversible consequences for its environment and culture.

Conclusion

Cinque Terre’s beauty and cultural significance make it a desirable destination for millions of tourists each year. However, the region is at a tipping point, where the very qualities that attract visitors are being threatened by the impacts of overtourism. While efforts are being made to manage the flow of tourists and protect the environment, the challenges are immense, and more comprehensive solutions may be needed to ensure that Cinque Terre can be enjoyed by future generations without losing its essence. The hidden costs of tourism in this fragile region serve as a stark reminder of the importance of sustainable travel practices and the need for careful management of our most treasured destinations.

For more information on the impact of overtourism in Cinque Terre and the actions being taken, you can explore the following sources:

The Reopening of Via dell’Amore: A New Chapter for Cinque Terre

Introduction

After a decade-long closure, the Via dell’Amore in Cinque Terre, Italy, has reopened, much to the delight of locals and tourists. This scenic path, renowned for its romantic views and historical significance, connects the villages of Riomaggiore and Manarola. The reopening, which began for residents on July 27, 2024, and for tourists on August 9, 2024, marks the culmination of extensive restoration efforts. Here, we explore what led to the closure, the restoration process, and what visitors can expect from the newly refurbished trail.

Historical Background

The Via dell’Amore, or “Path of Love,” was originally constructed in the 1930s to facilitate the building of a railway tunnel between Riomaggiore and Manarola. What started as a utilitarian path quickly became a beloved spot for romantic rendezvous, earning its evocative name. The path’s picturesque views of the Ligurian Sea and its ease of access made it a popular destination for tourists from around the world.

The Closure

In September 2012, a devastating landslide struck the Via dell’Amore, injuring four tourists and rendering the path unsafe. The combination of heavy rainfall and geological instability led to significant damage, prompting local authorities to close the trail indefinitely. The closure was a significant blow to the local tourism industry, as the Via dell’Amore was one of Cinque Terre’s main attractions.

Restoration Efforts

Restoring the Via dell’Amore was no small feat. The complex and costly project, estimated at €22 million (approximately $24 million), involved significant engineering and environmental work to ensure the path’s safety and sustainability. Restoration efforts included installing steel mesh barriers to prevent further rockfalls, planting nearly 10,000 plants to stabilize the hillside, and constructing an artificial tunnel for additional support. A geotechnical monitoring system was also implemented to detect any potential landslides, providing advanced warnings to prevent future incidents.

The Reopening

The path reopened to residents on July 27, 2024, with a broader opening to tourists on August 9, 2024. To manage the influx of visitors and preserve the trail, a reservation system has been implemented. Visitors must book a timed half-hour group tour, available online for €5 per person. The tour allows for up to 100 visitors per reservation slot, ensuring that no more than 400 people are on the path at any given hour.

The trail is now a one-way route from Riomaggiore to Manarola, a measure designed to control foot traffic and minimize wear and tear on the path. Guided tours provide not only breathtaking views of the Ligurian Sea but also insights into the history and restoration efforts of the Via dell’Amore.

Visitor Experience

Walking the Via dell’Amore today is a blend of natural beauty and historical reflection. The path offers stunning vistas of the rugged coastline, with the azure sea stretching out below. The newly planted vegetation and the careful integration of safety features ensure that the path blends seamlessly with its natural surroundings.

Visitors will appreciate the meticulous attention to detail in the restoration work. The pigmented concrete used for the path is designed to match the colors of the surrounding rocks, creating a visually harmonious experience. The steel mesh barriers, while essential for safety, are discreetly placed to minimize visual impact.

Sustainable Tourism

The reopening of the Via dell’Amore is part of a broader initiative to promote sustainable tourism in Cinque Terre. By limiting the number of visitors and requiring reservations, local authorities aim to protect the delicate environment and ensure that the path remains a treasured landmark for years to come. The restoration project’s emphasis on environmental integration and safety reflects a commitment to preserving Cinque Terre’s natural beauty while accommodating the many visitors who come to experience it.

Conclusion

The reopening of the Via dell’Amore is a significant milestone for Cinque Terre, symbolizing resilience and dedication to preserving one of Italy’s most romantic and scenic trails. The careful restoration and new visitor management strategies ensure that the path can be enjoyed safely and sustainably. As tourists and locals alike once again traverse this iconic route, the Via dell’Amore continues its legacy as a symbol of love, history, and natural beauty.

For more details and to make reservations, visitors can check the official Cinque Terre website here.

Experience the Culinary Delights and Natural Beauty of Tuscany at Agriturismo Montagna Verde

Nestled in the heart of Lunigiana, in the locality of Apella di Licciana Nardi, province of Massa Carrara, in high Tuscany, you will find the enchanting Agriturismo Montagna Verde. This agritourism destination is situated at an altitude of 660 meters, surrounded by the centuries-old chestnut groves of the Tuscan-Emilian Apennines National Park. The area was once ruled by the Malaspina, who were the uncontested lords of the entire territory.

The cozy interior of the Agriturismo Montagna Verde restaurant, with its stone walls and wooden beams, exuding rustic charm. The dining area offers stunning views of the surrounding Tuscan landscape, enhancing the dining experience

The pristine environment and nature blend seamlessly with the hospitality and kindness of the agritourism staff, values that have a long tradition in these lands of Lunigiana. The agritourism facility offers all the amenities one would expect from an excellent accommodation structure, but with something extra: the unique backdrop of an untouched landscape where history meets nature. This area has been recognized as a UNESCO MAB Reserve since May 2015.

blank

The agritourism is run by the family of Mario Maffei. A watchtower built in 1000 AD, which was later expanded into a defensive fortress in the 13th century and elevated to a bell tower and abbey in the 1700s, stands sentinel over the property. After years of neglect, thanks to the idea and commitment of Mario Maffei, the monastery regained its ancient splendor in 1995. Today, its imposing structure stands over more than 600 hectares of reserve, where guests can go horseback riding, trekking, and perhaps gather seasonal fruits such as wild strawberries, blueberries, chestnuts, and mushrooms, either alone or accompanied by expert guides.

The agritourism offers a restaurant in the central Torre building and accommodation in the renovated medieval village of Apella, less than 800 meters from the monastery. The apartments and rooms, all with private facilities, have been restored according to sustainable building criteria. On request, it is also possible to visit the laboratory where honey is produced, the chestnut dryers, the biopark, and the organic farm.

The Agriturismo Montagna Verde has received high praise on TripAdvisor, with a score of 4.5 out of 5 and ranking 1 out of 22 restaurants in Licciana Nardi. Reviewers have highlighted the quality of the food, the beauty of the location, and the friendliness of the staff. The restaurant offers a variety of dishes, including vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options. The reviews also mention the abundant portions and reasonable prices, with many guests praising the local, organic, and healthy food prepared at the restaurant.

Agriturismo Montagna Verde is not just a place to rest and enjoy the beauty of nature, but it’s also a culinary journey through the traditional flavors of Tuscany. The restaurant offers a variety of dishes that are a testament to the rich culinary heritage of the region, prepared with locally sourced, organic ingredients.

One of the standout dishes that you can enjoy at the restaurant is the “Tagliere della casa con sgabei e focaccia”. This is a house special platter that features a selection of local cheeses and cured meats, served with sgabei and focaccia. Sgabeo is a traditional Tuscan fried dough, light and fluffy, often enjoyed with cold cuts and cheese. The focaccia, a type of Italian flatbread, is baked to perfection, with a crisp exterior and a soft, airy interior.

"A rustic wooden table set with a platter of local cheeses and cured meats, accompanied by traditional Tuscan sgabei and focaccia. The backdrop of the stone walls of the restaurant adds to the authentic Tuscan dining experience."

Another dish that is a must-try is the “Tordei”. These are a type of pasta, similar to tortellini, that are a specialty of the Lunigiana region. They are typically filled with a mixture of meat or cheese and served with a rich and flavorful sauce.

A close-up shot of Tordei, a traditional pasta dish from the Lunigiana region of Tuscany. The pasta is filled with a rich mixture and served with a flavorful sauce, showcasing the culinary heritage of the region.

For meat lovers, the “Tagliata al lardo cotta nei testi” is a delight. This dish features a succulent steak cooked with lard in a traditional Tuscan method using “testi”, which are terracotta pans. The lard melts into the steak as it cooks, infusing it with a rich, savory flavor that is truly unforgettable.

A succulent steak, Tagliata al lardo cotta nei testi, cooked to perfection with lard in a traditional Tuscan terracotta pan. The melting lard infuses the steak with a rich, savory flavor, making it a must-try for meat lovers.

The restaurant itself exudes a rustic charm, with its stone walls and wooden beams, creating a warm and cozy atmosphere. The dining area offers stunning views of the surrounding landscape, making your dining experience even more enjoyable.

In conclusion, Agriturismo Montagna Verde offers a unique blend of history, nature, and gastronomy. It is the perfect destination for those seeking a peaceful holiday, in touch with nature, history, and good food, in a strategic and enviable position: just a few kilometers from the Parco dei Cento Laghi and the fabulous sea of the Cinque Terre and the Gulf of Poets, as well as the white beaches of Versilia, less than an hour’s drive from Lucca, Pisa, and Genoa

The Rebirth of Via dell’Amore: A Journey Through Italy’s Open-Air Museum

Italy, a country steeped in history and culture, is home to some of the world’s most breathtaking landscapes. Nestled within its heart is the Cinque Terre, a string of centuries-old seaside villages along the rugged Italian Riviera coastline. Among the many treasures of this region, the Via dell’Amore, or “Path of Love,” stands out as a symbol of romance and natural beauty. Closed for over a decade due to a landslide, this iconic path is set to partially reopen in May 2023, with a full reopening planned for 2024.

The Via dell’Amore, carved into the rock, offers a unique experience, giving the impression of walking suspended between sea and sky. This path, just over a kilometer long, connects two of the most picturesque pastel villages of the Eastern Liguria, Riomaggiore and Manarola, the heart of the Cinque Terre. The reopening of this path is eagerly anticipated by locals and tourists alike, promising a return to the romantic walks that have made it famous worldwide.

However, the reopening of the Via dell’Amore is not just about re-establishing a walking path. It’s about transforming this iconic route into an open-air museum, a living testament to the rich cultural and traditional heritage of the Cinque Terre. The Liguria Region, in agreement with the Cinque Terre National Park and the Municipality of Riomaggiore, is working on a cultural enhancement project that aims to offer insights related to the peculiar aspects of the landscape. This includes agro-forestry systems, urban nuclei, rural buildings, defensive and religious-devotional architectures, and the knowledge and trades linked to typical productions, all in function of sustainable tourism.

The local authorities, including the mayor of Riomaggiore, Fabrizia Pecunia, are developing strategies to manage the expected tourist flow and preserve the sustainability of the region. One of the ideas being considered is to make the path accessible only with the assistance of tour guides, to manage the visitor flow better and provide a more enriching experience. The goal is to allow visitors to truly get to know the Cinque Terre and its vast cultural heritage.

Over twenty million euros have been invested to secure the path, mostly using regional funds. The works of consolidation and hydrogeological recovery of the slopes will be carried out by the structure of the Extraordinary Commissioner of the Government against hydrogeological instability for the Liguria Region. This commitment to safety and preservation underscores the importance of the Via dell’Amore to the region and its people.

So, if you’re planning a trip to Italy, keep an eye out for the reopening of the Via dell’Amore. It promises to be more than just a scenic walk; it’s a journey through the heart and soul of the Cinque Terre. A walk along the Via dell’Amore is not just a walk; it’s an immersive experience into the rich cultural tapestry of the region. It’s a chance to step back in time and witness the timeless beauty of Italy’s stunning landscapes. It’s an opportunity to fall in love with Italy all over again.

Sources:

https://www.lanazione.it/economia/la-via-dellamore-riaprira-a-maggio-c7c0a5b1
https://programmazionestrategica.beniculturali.it/progetto/riomaggiore-via-dellamore/
https://siviaggia.it/notizie/riapre-passeggiata-piu-romantica-italia-museo-a-cielo-aperto/400028/